The W1070 and the H5380BD are two very similar projectors, so how do you decide which one to purchase? Both offer 3D capabilities, both are HD, each is portable, and the set-up won’t represent a challenge on either of these two systems. So what, if anything, set’s them apart? I’m going to provide you with an in-depth analysis of each projector, so that you’ll be armed with the knowledge need to make the right decision for you.
|ViewSonic PJD7820HD||BenQ W1070|
|Brightness||3,000 Lumens||2,000 Lumens|
|Lamp Life||6,000 hours (eco-mode)||6,000 hours (eco-mode)|
|Aspect Ratio||16:9 (HD)||16:9 (HD)|
|Image Size(cm)||140 - 760||101 - 596|
|Speakers||2.0 W Mono||10.0 W Mono|
|Audible Noise||35.0 dB||33.0 dB|
|Size(cm) (HxWxD)||140 - 760||10 x 31 x 24|
|Weight||2.1 kg kg||2.6 kg|
|Full Review||Coming Soon||Read Here|
|Amazon Price||Click Here||Click Here|
Portability and Design: Acer H5380BD vs BenQ W1070
The W1070 weighs 5.8 pounds, compared to the H5380BD’s 5.5 pounds, and they’re about the same size too. The w1070 measures 4.29 inches in height, by 12.28 inches of width, and has 9.60 inches of depth, while the Acer H5380BD measures 3.66 inches of height, by 8.77 inches of width, and comes at a depth of 12.36 inches. These measurements are both pretty comfortably into the standard portable bracket, although the Benq w1070 is slightly bigger, I doubt you’d notice the difference. The Benq is however more portable, because it has 10 Watt speakers, whereas with the Acer’s 2 Watt speaker, you couldn’t really take it anywhere that doesn’t have a stereo sound system. Read full BenQ W1070 review.
Performance: Acer H5380BD vs BenQ W1070
The W1070 has an excellent HD picture at full HD 1080p resolution. Its color processing is pretty good too, with the ability to produce 1.07 billion colors, and although the contrast ratio, at 10,000:1, could have been higher; it’s still a fair amount for a projector at this price. Its good all of the time, but rarely outstanding. The H5380BD only has a resolution of 720p so at first many buyers would consider it inferior, but this isn’t so. With it’s 13000:1 contrast ratio blacks and whites appear sharper and more crisp than the W1070, and the color technology is exceptional. You’ll get a superior picture with the Acer, but while it keeps motion distortion to a minimum, it does have a slight tendency to show rainbow artifacts. These are colors that pop up on screen at impromptu times, and they’re a common result of using DLP technology. So, if you are particularly bothered by such things, perhaps you’d be best going for the reliably good w1070, rather than the amazing, but erratic H5380BD.
The set-ups on these are reasonably easy, but both have small issues. The H5380BD has connectors placed on either side of the unit, which is quite a bizarre design decision, and it doesn’t have very much zoom. The optical zoom on the W1070 is also limited; but where they both succeed is in versatility of screen adjustments. They have vertical shifts, which means you don’t have to use the keystone to adjust the image, and you thereby avoid importing distortions associated with keystone.
Regarding brightness, the Benq W1070 is a single-chip projector, which means everything it does comes from one chip rather than three, and these tend to have lower color brightness, than white brightness. Manufacturers often claim the brightness is equal, and the Benq is listed at 2200 lumens, but this isn’t the case, and it leaks light from the huge grills located at its front. The H5380BD, also has lower than listed color brightness, but it starts out with 3000 lumens, so you’re still getting more brightness than with the Benq. It’s not much more though. and buyers can expect good pictures up to 100 inches on both.
Despite it’s slight artifact problem, the Acer performs better than the Benq in terms of HD quality, but in 3D mode, the Benq w1070 wins the day. The w1070 has 1.4a HDMI, and is compatible with all forms of 3D, so being 1080p, it would be considered a full 3D projector. It’s listed as 3D ready, because it doesn’t come with glasses, not because the picture quality or 3D technology isn’t there. The H5380BD meanwhile has a 720p native resolution, so it will never give you full 3D images, because full 3D is 1080p in each eye. It can be upscaled to 1080p. which means your projector will translate 720p into 1080p, but in the majority of cases upscaling falls short of full 1080p. So, the best you’re gonna get on the H5380BD is great pictures, but not quite full 3D. Read full review.
Finally. the Benq excels in sound too, with its 10 Watt speakers, which will probably be the norm in 5 years, but are quite rare on low priced projectors right now. The Acer H5380BD only has 2 Watt speakers, and that’s a big difference so to get good sound you’ll have to hook it up to a stereo system.
Both of these are great systems, but while the Acer is better, if a little unpredictable for HD, the w1070 is better for 3D. So it depends what you’ll be using it for. Certainly as far as sound goes, the w1070 is vastly superior, but where brightness is concerned the H5380BD prevails. I’d recommend both projectors, but if you’re not a big 3D fan, go for the Acer.